SPY, QQQ After the ISM Selloff, Before ADP
I don’t read the ISM report. I don’t read the JOLTS number either. What I read is the chart after everyone else has already reacted to both. Yesterday gave me a clean version of that.
SPY closed Monday at $767.05, down a small 0.30% from Friday’s $769.35. Nothing unusual there — the kind of quiet drift that doesn’t tell you much of anything. Then Tuesday came, and with it the 10am ET data: ISM Manufacturing PMI and JOLTS Job Openings, both released back to back.
SPY opened the day at $762.01, already below Monday’s close before the number even hit. It pushed up to a high of $764.67, then spent the session bleeding down to $759.48 before closing at $761.78. That’s a 0.69% drop from Monday, and one of the weaker closes SPY has printed in the past two weeks.
QQQ fell harder
QQQ told a different story in degree, not direction. Monday it actually closed green — $716.76, up a thin 0.05% from Friday’s $716.43. Then Tuesday it opened at $707.39, nearly nine dollars below where it had just closed. It touched $712.30 on the high, sank to $704.66, and settled at $707.64. That’s a 1.27% single-day drop — nearly double what SPY absorbed.
I don’t need to know why the Nasdaq-heavy names took the sharper hit to mark it. Growth and tech names carry more duration risk around macro surprises than the broader index does. That’s a mechanical fact about how these instruments tend to behave, not a prediction I’m making about this specific print. The chart just confirms it did that again yesterday.
Look at the shape of each candle and you get the same story without a single headline. SPY opened below Monday’s close, tried once to climb back through it, failed at $764.67, and spent the rest of the session giving ground. That’s a fade — early strength sold into, no recovery by the close. QQQ skipped the polite version entirely. It gapped down almost nine dollars at the open and never got back near where it started. One index absorbed the shock in installments. The other took it in a single hit before the opening bell had even settled.
I mention the shape because it matters more to me than the size of the move. A slow bleed and a hard gap can end at similar percentages and still mean different things about who was positioned which way heading in. I don’t need to reconstruct the positioning to use that difference — I just note it, mark where each one stopped, and move on.
What I don’t know, and won’t pretend to
I don’t have the actual ISM Manufacturing number. I don’t have the actual JOLTS figure. I know the forecasts going in — 55.2 for ISM against a prior 55.6, 7.33 million for JOLTS against a prior 7.36 million — but a forecast isn’t an outcome, and I’m not going to write as though I saw a number I never saw.
What I have instead is the only thing that ever mattered to me anyway: where price went after the data hit, and where it stopped. QQQ stopped falling somewhere between $704.66 and $707.64. SPY stopped between $759.48 and $761.78. Those are the two zones I’m marking on my chart this morning. Not because I know what caused the move — because that’s where sellers ran out and buyers showed up, whatever their reasons were.
Today isn’t quiet either
Wednesday carries its own lineup. ADP Non-Farm Employment Change lands at 8:15am ET, forecast at 47K against a prior 44K. Factory Orders follow at 10:00am ET, forecast 0.7% against a prior negative 0.3%. Then the Fed’s Beige Book drops at 2:00pm ET.
ADP gets treated as an informal preview of Friday’s official jobs report. That’s just how the calendar works — one lands two days before the other, so people compare them. The two numbers frequently diverge from each other, sometimes by a wide margin, and that’s true in general, not a call I’m making about what happens this week specifically. I’m not going to sit here and tell you ADP prints strong or weak today. I don’t know yet. Nobody does until 8:15 hits.
Factory Orders at 10am carries less weight on its own, but it lands close enough to the ADP release that the two can compound each other’s reaction if they surprise in the same direction. Then the Beige Book at 2pm is a different animal entirely — no single number, just the Fed’s regional read on how business actually feels on the ground. It rarely moves price the way a jobs number does, but it can color how the market interprets everything that came before it that day. Three separate inputs, three separate windows for price to reveal something, all before Friday’s number closes out the week.
What I will do is the same thing I did yesterday: wait for the print, watch where price actually goes, and see whether it respects the zones left over from Tuesday’s selloff or blows straight through them. If QQQ can’t reclaim the $707–$712 range with any conviction after the data, that tells me more than any forecast number could. If SPY holds above $760 through a data day, that’s information too.
Marking, not guessing
Three data points today, one more Friday. That’s a lot of scheduled noise packed into four trading days. My job through all of it stays the same as it was before any of these events were on the calendar: draw the line where price already proved something, then let the market come back and answer the question on its own.
I spent years thinking I needed to know why price moved before I could trust where it stopped. It took a long time to accept that the stopping point is the only part I actually need.
Join the free Static chart room →
Disclosure: that’s an affiliate link — I may earn a commission if you join a paid tier later, at no extra cost to you. The free room is free.
Related reading